21 Guns by Green Day – What key?

21 Guns by Green Day – What key?

21 guns

Excellent question – 21 Guns by Green Day – is it in D minor or F major? And how to tell?

After all, both scales share the same notes:

  • F G A Bb C D E F. F major.
  • D E F G A Bb C D. D minor. Same notes, just started on a different root.

Why is that?

D is the relative minor of F major. D is the Aeolian mode. D is the sixth mode. Whatever you wanna call it, the two go together and F will be on the outside rim of the cycle of fifths sporting one flat, and D minor will be right below it (typically inside the circle).

I think one of the most important skills as an informed band mate you can possess is to know the correct key of a song.

Especially when you work with singers, that comes in really handy!

This article gives you a great summary on how to find the key of a song. Hint: it is usually not the first chord, but rather the last! It lists simple guidelines and rules and all exceptions I could think of. I like complex stuff put in simple and memorizable terms, so check it out if you haven’t read it before. I think this stuff is must-know for a bass player! After all, we deal with roots all the time!

Now this 21 Guns song a Quoran is asking about exemplifies an ambiguous key center. I make a case for what I think it is – what do you think?

If you check it out, you also get rewarded with a hilarious video by an Australian comedy band, talking about four note chords. Incidentally, 21 Guns is exactly one of those. Just in a different order, hehe.

If your browser does not display the box below go here.

Read Ariane Cap’s answer to How do you know when a scale is in a major or it’s relative minor, when the notes are same? Is 21 Guns in F major or D minor? on Quora

Music THeory for the Bass Player The Course

Share this

Ready to Play Like You Always Wanted?

Step-by-Step Self Study Courses

Explore our full library of self-study bass courses – each one part of a structured method designed to build real skills, one step at a time. Perfect if you love learning on your own. Start any time. You can add support options later when you are ready. 

Unmatched Support Options

All of our courses can be taken on your own or with cohort support – that means weekly homework, accountability, peer motivation, and live meetings with Ari. Perfect if you want structure, support, and real momentum. 
You can also join LIVE Practice Events with Ari.

Click below to find out what’s offered right now.

2 Replies to “21 Guns by Green Day – What key?”

  1. Fantastic post Ariane! I am going through the course now and picking pieces to practice on the side and this recently came up (Rolling in the Deep by Adele) … simple song, but the key had me confused.

    By the way, the music comedy video was great as well … informative and funny. Things like this stick because they are memorable.

    Lastly, I like anything posted about Green Day. 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

Get free useful bass info into your inbox!

Videos • Tips • Practice Hacks • Transcriptions